at first blush, $108 a year may not seem like much just $9 a month or a couple of bucks each week.
<
But, for the 120,000 people in the Wisconsin Retirement System's Fixed Trust Fund, the $108 annual increase in their pension amounts to a victory over a complicated system that would have provided them with no increase in 2004.
<
When the Legislature passed Act 11 in 1999, it changed the "smoothing" formula for determining whether dividends would be paid, or essentially, whether increases would occur. Under the previous Transaction Amortization Account, the changes were calculated over a 14-year period. Under the newer Market Recognition Account, the smoothing is more volatile at five years.
<
The averaging had little effect on things when the fund was chugging along returning healthy dividends, but things changed when the fund started experiencing losses in 2000.
<
The fund lost 0.8 percent in 2000, 2.3 percent in 2001 and 8.8 percent in 2002. The losses resulted in retirees receiving no increase in benefits last year for the first time since 1982 when the Wisconsin Retirement System, the State Teachers Retirement System and the Milwaukee Teachers Retirement System merged.
<
The losses were on top of a projected 8 percent increase in the fund.
<
With an improved economy and stock market, the Fixed Trust Fund experienced a 24.1 percent increase in 2003, but no benefit increases for retirees in 2004 were planned.
<
The averaging or smoothing mechanism for the past five years meant the fund had averaged less than a 2 percent increase. State law requires at least a 2 percent increase before dividends are authorized.
<
"We had a lot of people upset because the fund had turned around, but no increase was in their immediate future," said Julie Reneau, the administrator of the Division of Retirement Services at the Department of Employee Trust Funds.
<
"The three years of losses prevented us from increasing the benefits," she said.
<
Relief is on the way. The Joint Survey Committee on Retirement Systems last week unanimously approved legislation that changes the trigger from 2 percent to 0.5 percent.
<
"There would be no problem at all meeting the 0.5 percent requirement," said Pam Henning, director of the department's Office of Strategic Services. "In fact, we were very close to the 2 percent, but .
.. not quite there."
<The change means that retirees in the Fixed Fund will see an average increase of $108 in 2004 based on a monthly benefit of $1,800. But the change will also improve the benefits outlook down the road.
<
"We were making projections as far as 2007 and beyond," Henning said. "It was clear there needed to be a significant increase in returns on investments, so this change is going to help create a situation in which, hopefully, we won't have to go through another year like 2003 when no increase was paid."
<
The legislation passed by the committee retains a measure that reduces benefits when there are losses of 0.5 percent or more, but allows the Wisconsin Retirement Board to modify the triggers by administrative rule.
<
While the change to a five-year averaging mechanism put more volatility into the system, it was a necessary change recommended by the fund's actuary, Gabriel Roeder Smith and Co., Reneau said.
<
"The former system was averaging on a 14-year basis," she said. "We were told that most funds our size had a four- to seven-year mechanism.
<
"The real benefit of the new mechanism is that it recognized generational investments," Reneau said. "At 14 years, the formula is looking at investments from a different time."
<
Two identical bills, AB-692 and SB-344, were approved by the joint committee. The bills now go to the labor committees in each house.
<
Rep. Daniel Vrakas, R-Hartland says he doesn't see any problems ahead for the legislation. Vrakas is the Assembly co-chairman of the joint committee.
<
"This is not an increase in terms of payments into the fund," Vrakas said. "It's merely a change to allow the retirees to get what is theirs a little sooner."
<
Stan Milam, of Capitol News Service, has covered state government since 1983. He can be reached at (608) 251-8585; send e-mail to cns@chorus.net.