madison.com  Marketplace | Jobs | Autos | Homes | Rentals | Obits | Weather | Archives  

WSJ homeAnnouncementsBook of businessClassifieds searchEntertainmentPhoto reprintsStory archivesContact staffEamil a letter to the editor

Reader Services
Subscribe
Renew your subscription
Temporary stop
Carrier opportunities
Newspapers In Education
> More reader services

Advertiser services:
Place a Classified ad
Media kit
Digital file requirements
> More advertiser services


Special reports
Madison public art
 
Community links
Freedom's answer
 

Supreme Court candidates present their cases at forum
6:15 PM 1/30/03
Anita Clark Wisconsin State Journal

Each of three candidates for the Wisconsin Supreme Court assured an audience of lawyers Tuesday that he or she has precisely the right qualifications to join the state's highest court.

They also sparred over how to pay for judicial campaigns and whether judges should express their opinion on abortion rights.

About 200 people attended the forum at the Concourse Hotel, sponsored by the Dane County Bar Association, for the candidates, one of whom will be eliminated in the non-partisan Feb. 18 primary election.

The candidates:

  • Edward Brunner, 54, Rice Lake, a circuit judge in Barron County and chief judge of his 13-county district, who emphasizes his legal and community experience and insists that judicial candidates should not accept donations from political action committees.

  • Paul Higginbotham, 48, Madison, a circuit judge in Dane County, who touts the diversity of his background and his willingness to listen to people in court. If elected, he would be Wisconsin's first African American on the Supreme Court.

  • Pat Roggensack, 62, Madison, a judge on the Fourth District Court of Appeals who notes no sitting justice has been an appeals judge and says it's time for Wisconsin to examine and improve how its appeals courts operate in relation to the top court.

    Brunner returned several times to his crusade against judges accepting money from political action committees. Recent scandals in Milwaukee County and at the Capitol are "a disgrace to our government" and PAC money doesn't belong in the court system, he said.

    Higginbotham said "taking PAC money does not mean that one is dirty," and said television ads are an important way for candidates to introduce themselves to voters.

    Roggensack said she doesn't think PAC money is an issue and it's "simply not accurate" to link it to the scandals.

    An audience member asked the candidates about constitutional protection for abortion rights.

    Roggensack said it's improper to take a position on an issue that could come before the court.

    "I take no substantive position except to tell you that I will enforce the law," she said.

    Brunner, too, said he could not discuss how he would rule on a potential future case, but said he believes in a woman's right to choose.

    Higginbotham said Wisconsin "absolutely" needs a constitutional amendment protecting abortion rights. "It's about a woman's power over herself and a woman's ability to control her own life," he said.

    The winner of the April 1 election will replace Justice William Bablitch, who is retiring.

  • Copyright © 2002 Wisconsin State Journal


    News from AP

    Historic health care bill clears Senate hurdle

    RI bishop asked Kennedy in 2007 to avoid Communion

    Lawyer: 9/11 defendants want platform for views

    Israeli aircraft strike Gaza targets

    Sizing up the Kennedy dynasty's next generation

    Survivors recount China mine disaster; 92 dead

    More Americans expected to travel for Thanksgiving

    Canadian woman loses benefits over Facebook photo

    `New Moon' wolfs down $140.7M in opening weekend

    Murray beats Del Potro in 1st match at ATP finals