Now that state lawmakers have received a green light from an important
committee, they should swiftly lift the state's 24-year-old moratorium on
nuclear power plant construction.
Wisconsin can no longer afford to rule out new nuclear power sources.
The green light came from the Governor's Global Warming Task Force,
comprising 29 representatives of groups ranging from environmental organizations
to corporations to government.
In its plan for addressing global warming, the task force voted to include a
recommendation to modify the nuclear plant moratorium. The modification would
permit new nuclear plants to be considered as an option to meet the state's
long-term energy needs.
The task force deserves credit for taking on the controversial topic of
nuclear energy. In contrast, a group of 12 Midwest governors, including
Wisconsin Gov. Jim Doyle, decided nuclear power was too politically charged to
include in an energy policy agreement last year.
Wisconsin is already home to three nuclear reactors. But after those reactors
were built, the Legislature barred approval of another nuclear plant until there
is a facility with capacity to store spent nuclear fuel from all nuclear plants
in the state. The law is, in effect, a moratorium.
The task force recommended lowering the barrier, requiring only that any
plant have a reasonable, stringent and economical waste disposal plan.
The task force also added some regulatory hurdles for any new nuclear plant.
But the recommendation to lower the initial barrier is a breakthrough that
lawmakers should use as their signal to end the moratorium, just as the
Legislature's own special committee on nuclear power recommended in 2007.
Nuclear power is no magic solution to energy problems. The high cost of plant
construction and questions about long-term waste disposal are drawbacks.
The task force correctly identified conservation and energy efficiency, which
can reduce the demand for new power plants, as the state's top priorities.
Renewable wind power and biomass are also promising power sources.
But conservation, efficiency and renewables are unlikely to be sufficient
answers for a growing demand for electricity. Nuclear power offers the important
advantage of being free of most air pollution, including mercury and the
greenhouse gases that contribute to global warming. And nuclear fuel is
cheap.
With growing concern about global warming, greater confidence in nuclear
safety and more favorable cost comparisons, it makes sense to consider nuclear
power as an option.